The Insider’s Guide: 4 Red Flags to Spot Before Hiring a College Counselor

The college admissions process can feel like a labyrinth. With student-to-counselor ratios in American high schools hovering around a staggering 385:1 (which Is actually better than It used to be), it’s no wonder that many families feel lost. In search of guidance, many turn to Independent Educational Consultants (IECs) for support.

An Independent college counselor can be an invaluable partner, bringing clarity and strategy to a stressful process. A bad one, however, can waste your money and, worse, add to the anxiety by providing misinformed guidance.

As someone with 15 years of experience on "both sides of the desk"—both in high school counseling offices and ollege admission offices—I believe families deserve to know what separates genuine expertise from a confident sales pitch. Before you invest in an independent counselor, here are four critical areas to investigate.

1. Is their expertise real or just a credential?

The single most important factor in a counselor’s ability to help is their background. Many consultants market themselves as "experts" based on a certification (looking at you, West Coast counseling certificate), an unrelated advanced degree, or their personal experience as a parent who guided their own child into college.

While well-intentioned, these are not substitutes for professional, institutional experience.

• What to Ask: “Have you ever worked in a university admissions office or a high school college counseling department?”

• Why it Matters: Someone with "both sides of the desk" experience understands how decisions are actually made inside an admissions office. Being a season admissions reader, although beneficial to the school, does not count as expertise. They’ve read thousands of applications, they understand institutional priorities, and they know what makes a candidate stand out (pr not). Be wary of "opaque expertise"; a great consultant will be proud to share their direct, relevant experience.

2. Are they a partner or a paywall?

A consultant’s willingness to share information is a powerful indicator of their philosophy. Is their goal to empower you with knowledge, or to keep it guarded as a trade secret? With EduTate, we try to strike as much of a balance as possible. We want you to have all of the information, but we also have to mark the line for when you need 1-on-1 guidance.

• What to Ask: “What kind of free information or resources do you make available?”

• Why it Matters: Trust is built on transparency. A consultant who is genuinely committed to helping students will often provide valuable content—blog posts, webinars, resource lists—to help all families, not just their paying clients. If every piece of useful advice is hidden behind a paywall, it suggests a business model that is more transactional than relational.

3. Are they promising the impossible?

This is one of the brightest red flags. Be extremely cautious of any IEC who guarantees—or even strongly implies—they can get your student into an Ivy League or other "Top 25" institution.

• What to Ask: “How do you define success for the students you work with?”

• Why it Matters: No one can guarantee admission to highly selective universities. Full stop. The process is far too unpredictable. A focus on "guaranteed" results often leads to poor advice that prioritizes prestige over the student's actual needs, interests, and well-being. An ethical counselor defines success by helping a student find a college where they will thrive—a concept known as "fit." This is especially crucial for the "Invisible Middle," the nearly 73% of students who attend excellent schools outside of the ultra-elite "Top 100".

4. Do they understand their role (and the student’s)?

Your student has spent years doing the hard work: taking challenging classes, pursuing their passions, and growing as a person. A consultant’s job is not to magically transform them, but to help them articulate their story in the most compelling way possible.

• What to Ask: “How do you see your role in partnership with my student?”

• Why it Matters: A great counselor is a mentor and a guide. They work to amplify the student's voice, not replace it. Be wary of consultants who seem to take all the credit for their students’ acceptances. The student is the hero of this journey; the counselor is their trusted guide on the side.

• 
  

Ultimately, the college admissions journey belongs to one person: the student. At EduTate, we are deeply committed to honoring their work and amplifying their voice. The principles of honesty, transparency, and genuine expertise are the bedrock of our practice because it's how we earn the right to be a partner on that journey. We see it as a privilege to help guide your student toward their next chapter.

-JT